It is not unusual for comic book
artists to occasionally borrow ideas from each other. Normally
the borrowings are taken from main subjects and then reworked to
suit the specific plotline the artist requires. Nothing odious -
as long as the artist does not engage in pure plagiarism. It is
another matter when graphic front covers or story panels get
duplicated!
In this page you will be presented to a selection of front covers
which Carl Barks made for the Uncle Scrooge issues. Barks' front
covers for this particular character were all quite special for
the simple fact that Scrooge is always portrayed as a wealthy
miser, so the main subject would not be practical for others to
replicate. Except for one comic book series - the stories with 'The
Richest Kid in the World' better known as
Richie Rich*. The main storyline deals with a boy who seems to
have unlimited funds at his disposal, thus making him somewhat
comparable to Scrooge.
This page presents you to a comparative listing between a few
Barks front covers - placed in chronological order after issues -
followed by a similar Richie Rich front cover published some time
later. It is now up to you to decide if you think that Barks and
his cover concepts have been victims to acts of plagiarism...
* The American website Forbes
publishes an annual listing describing the 15 most wealthy,
fictional characters. You would think that Scrooge is the
undisputed number 1 from year to year (after all, he has a full
money bin, money filling all the banks, assets in all countries,
and a 24 carat gold moon orbiting in space), but this is not
necessarily the case! For instance, in 2005 Scrooge was merely
deemed number 6 with Richie Rich as number 3 - and number 1 that
years was Santa Claus!!!
U$08 - December 1954 |
|
|
|
RR Millions 8
- March 1962 |
|
U$10 - June 1955 |
|
|
|
RR Billions 12 - September 1976 |
|
U$12 - December 1955 |
|
|
|
RR Millions 22 - March 1964 |
|
U$18 - June 1957 |
|
|
|
RR 44 - April 1966 |
|
U$19 - September 1957 |
|
|
|
RR Money World 2 - November 1972 |
|
U$20 - December 1957 |
|
|
|
RR Cash 20 - November 1977 |
|
U$28 - December 1959 |
|
|
|
RR Millions 35 - May 1966 |
|
U$33 - March 1961 |
|
|
|
RR Bank Books 24 - August 1976 |
|
U$34 - June 1961 |
|
|
|
RR Millions 55 - September 1972 |
|
EXTRA
Below you are presented to a very
strange coincidence. Once again, a U$ issue and a RR
issue have an identical theme and layout, but the
difference is that neither of the artists could have
plagiarized the other. As you can see, the issues were
published practically at the same time...
|
U$39 - September 1962 |
|
|
|
RR 10 - May 1962 |
|
http://www.cbarks.dk/THEPLAGIARISM.htm |
|
Date 2011-10-01 |